The honest one

Mr. Knightley

The only person in Highbury who tells Emma the truth.

Emma · 1815

Mr. Knightley has known Emma Woodhouse all her life, and he is the only person who regularly tells her when she is wrong. He scolds her matchmaking, warns her about her schemes and, in the novel’s most painful scene, tells her plainly how cruel she was to poor Miss Bates.

What makes him a hero is not that he criticizes her, but why. He is the one man in the book who sees Emma clearly and likes her anyway, and he trusts her to do better.

Darcy or Knightley? It’s the great Austen debate. Darcy has the grand gesture. Knightley has the honesty.

In their own words

Best lines

“I cannot see you acting wrong, without a remonstrance.”
To Emma, after Box Hill
“It was badly done, indeed!”
On Emma’s joke at Miss Bates’s expense
“If I loved you less, I might be able to talk about it more.”
His proposal to Emma

Every quote checked against the original text of Emma. No film-only lines.

Wear it

In a World of Wickhams, Be a Darcy

Not a Knightley design yet. Until then, the principle is the same: be the honest one.

Ad · Our own design, sold on Amazon.com. If you buy, we earn from the sale.

Darcy or Knightley? Cast your vote →

More characters